*** WARNING: Spoilers abound for season 6 of Dexter***
TITLE: Dexter
STARRING: Michael C. Hall, Jennifer Carpenter, Colin Hanks, Edward James Olmos, Desmond Harrington
EPISODES: 12
NETWORK: Showtime
FINALE DATE: December 18, 2011
By Rob Siebert
Editor, Fanboy Wonder
Yep, that was a cliffhanger right there.
If Dexter has proven anything in its six-year run on Showtime, it’s that it has a knack for delivering pulse-pounding cliffhangers. That trend continued this year, as Dexter rushed to save the day from Travis, who was holding his son Harrison hostage. But the true pulse-pounder didn’t come until the last 10 seconds of the episode, when the series reached a moment it’s been building up to since the beginning: Dexter’s sister Deb, the most honest and straight-laced cop you’ll ever meet, discovers her brother is a murderer as she sees him plunge a knife in Travis’ torso. All Dexter can bring himself to say is: “Oh God…” Then we cut to black.
This is obviously very similar to what they did during the final moments of season 4, when Dexter found his wife Rita dead in a bathtub. In terms of status quo shattering consequences, this moment is bigger than that one. But from the standpoint of artistic quality, it wasn’t as well done as season 4. For one thing, season 4 was without question the best the show has ever been. It had the best villain, Harrison was in Dexter’s life for the first time, and the story was so compelling it was almost addictive. Rita’s death was preceded by an excellent season of television. Deb’s discovery was preceded by a season that was strictly good. Like season 5, it had it’s moments, but we’ve seen better from Dexter. Also, viewers were completely blindsided by Rita’s death. Deb learning Dexter’s secret seemed to have been building for awhile, at least as far back as the finale of season 5. It still packed a hell of a punch, but I was able to brace myself for it.
One of the big themes this season revolved around religion, and how it can inspire people to do things that are both great and terrible. This was personified with the Brother Sam character, a murderer turned minister, as well as Professor Gellar and Travis, two killers who base their murders on religious texts. Toward the beginning of the season, Dexter ponders redemption quite a bit. He usually subscribes to the idea that a leopard can’t change his spots. But Brother Sam appears to have done just that using the power of faith. This leads Dexter to wonder whether he can will himself to change, and finally quiet his dark passenger. It’s interesting to see Dexter ask these questions, though I thought the character had put those sort of thoughts out of his mind back in season two, when he stop killing as if it were an addiction. Granted, he’s in a much different place now than he was then, and I suppose ridding yourself of the need to kill people is always a task worth attempting.
The Deb character evolved a great deal this season, not only by stepping into the lieutenant role, but by getting herself into therapy to sort out what a mess her life has been in recent years. Deb settled into that role about as neurotically and uncomfortably as we expected her to. But during episode 11 her story took a very awkward swerve. In therapy, Deb came to realize that she has developed complex romantic feelings for Dexter (remember, they’re foster siblings). She’s about to verbalize those feelings to him when she discovers he’s a killer. This struck me as an extremely odd direction to take her character. Deb spent much of the later half of the season analyzing her relationship with Dexter, and how important he is to her. But why did that have to lead to a romantic twist? Yes, a lot of terrible things have happened to Deb in recent years, and Dexter has always been there to support her. But he’s still her brother. Blood or not, developing an incestuous fixation on Dexter doesn’t necessarily place Deb in a favorable light. Might that happen in real life? I suppose. But for the purposes of a TV show, it left me scratching my head.
In terms of villainy, while Colin Hanks and Edward James Olmos weren’t on par with John Lithgow’s performance as the Trinity killer in season 4, they proved very worthy adversaries. Hanks in particular came off very strong this season, as his character underwent the most radical changes. Professor Gellar’s status as a figment of Travis’ imagination was a pleasant surprise, and made the Travis character look that much more twisted. I always enjoy when storytellers are able to do that. For most of the season we were rooting for Travis, thinking he was a victim of Gellar’s manipulation. As it turned out, the opposite was true. Travis was the mastermind and Gellar was the victim. Hanks and Olmos deserve a lot of credit for pulling that dynamic off.
The show trimmed some fat this season. Deb’s relationship with Quinn was ended, as was the marriage between Batista and LaGuerta. In response, Quinn turned to the bottle and Batista underwent a bit of a mid-life crisis. Oddly enough, LaGuerta really turned heel this season, returning to some of her puppetmaster antics from season 1. She softened up a bit during the last two episodes, but overall she was a villain this season. It was a complete switch from what her character has been like in recent years.
I’m confused about the Louis Greene character, and his possession of the prosthetic hand from the Ice Truck Killer case in season 1. He got the hand through shady means, then Dexter hurt his feelings…so he sent the hand to Dexter’s apartment? Why? How does he benefit from Dexter having the hand? Yes, Dexter and the Ice Truck Killer have a very deep connection: They were brothers. But Louis doesn’t know that. What’s the point? Am I missing something? I’m wondering if this is a loose end they’ll dive into again next season.
The “Nebraska” episode from this season catches a bit of heat in the current issue of Entertainment Weekly. Aired mid-season, the episode takes place after Brother Sam is shot and killed, and Dex deals with the loss by driving to Nebraska to find Trinity’s son Jonah, who may have just murdered his mother and sister. Along for the ride is Brian, Dexter’s deceased brother/the Ice Truck Killer, who is merely a figment of Dexter’s mind. The episode really did nothing to further the story, and Dexter seemed to act largely out-of-character, shirking his responsibilities and even killing on a whim. It wasn’t outright harmful, though. And it was nice to see Christian Camargo back as Brian, if only for a little while.
We didn’t get to see Dexter ponder his own righteousness as much as I was hoping for this season, though we did get a nice little monologue from him when he finally got Travis on his table. Still, I thoroughly enjoyed the religion/spirituality theme this season. Who better to ponder the virtues of the universe than a man who kills for what he believes are just causes?
All in all, a good season. Not great, but good. Next season we’re obviously in for big changes. Deb knows Dexter’s secret now. Will she be able to live with it, as she does in the books? Or will this sudden revelation send her over the edge? How much trauma can one person truly endure?
Perhaps that’ll be the big theme for next season…
Front page image, and images 1 & 2 from dextergr.blogspot.com. Image 3 from dexter.wikia.com.