Blatant Insubordination: What I Want To See In Arkham City
- August 15th, 2010
- By Rob
- Write comment
***Blatant Insubordination is a regular column published on Primary Ignition by Rob Siebert, editor and Fanboy Wonder. The views reflected in it are his alone, and do not reflect those of the staff of Primary Ignition.***
Eric Stuckart actually broke the news even before DC Entertainment did. The sequel to Batman: Arkham Asylum, by far the best Batman video game ever, will get a sequel in fall 2011. Entitled Arkham City, the game apparently revolves around the asylum being temporarily relocated into downtown Gotham, and the mayhem that ensues.
Now, I don’t mean to brag, but it would be hard for you to find a bigger Batman fan than me. I’m not going to say I’m the world’s BIGGEST Batman buff, but I’m certainly in the top echelon. I know the characters, I know the mythology, and I’ve seen this world portrayed in every medium from comics, to film, to television, to video games, to board games to novels, etc. Long story short, I know my Batman. And as a Batman fan, these are the things I’m hoping to see during my visit to Arkham City.
1. Let Me Roam Through Gotham City
Arkham Asylum gave the player a decent amount of freedom. Between missions, we were more or less allowed to roam the Asylum grounds at will, hunting for Easter Eggs and Riddler trophies. But in this game, I want a little of that Grand Theft Auto magic. I want to be able to swing from rooftops, see police headquarters and Crime Alley, and go on some larger-scale Riddler sidequests. Just as The Empire Strikes Back had to be a larger-scale film than Star Wars, Arkham City must be bigger than Asylum. After all, it IS a city…
2. Explore The Batman/Catwoman Dynamic
Based on the teaser imagery we got from Game Informer last week, it seems like Catwoman will be a major part of Arkham City. Firstly, can I just say how happy I am that the design team stayed faithful to the modern incarnation of Catwoman? They seem to have adapted the texture of her costume to fit the look of the game, but other than that, they’re using the costume the character has had for the past 9 years or so. Mad props.
In the comics, Catwoman balances between hero and villainess, and that’s exactly what I’d like to see her do in Arkham City. Some of the best stories involving Catwoman cast her as an x-factor, where neither the characters nor the audience know what her true motivation is. I’m not saying we should spend the entire game wondering what she’s really up to, but maybe tease us a bit about what she really thinks about Batman, the Arkham situation, etc.
Plus, Batman and Catwoman have been flirting for decades now. Let’s see some of that chemistry in the game. Her flirty, sultry nature against Batman’s all-business attitude. Sources say Debi Mae West is doing Catwoman’s voice in this game. I haven’t heard any of her work in Metal Gear Solid or Naruto, but if she can put the right spin on the character, it’ll be gold.
3. More Cool Character Designs
One thing I really respect about the Arkham Asylum game is that it respects the source material, but it’s not tied down by it. Case in point, the look of a character like The Scarecrow. Here’s a character that’s supposed to personify raw fear, but it’s sometimes hard to convey that visually. To most of us, scarecrows aren’t really scary. Over the years, creators have tried various tricks to make the character spookier, while still trying to maintain a “scarecrow” look. Some attempts have been more successful than others…
…but we’d NEVER seen anything like this. A man in tattered rags, wearing a noose around his neck, speaking through a gas mask, with BIG HONKIN’ NEEDLES on his hand! He looks more like the bad guy in a slasher movie than a melodramatic supervillain! This Freddy Krueger vibe was brilliance, and I hope to see this incarnation of Scarecrow in the new game.
In Arkham City, designers have room to play with a lot of new characters, like Two-Face, Mr. Freeze and hopefully The Penguin and Black Mask. I’m interested to see what they do this time around. Even the little things, like the texture and small details on Batman’s costume, were wonderful.
But guys, if you’re going to use Bane again, can we tone down his look a bit? He was the only character I looked at and said: “That’s too much.”
4. More Voices In Batman’s Head
I’m not sure characters like Robin or Nightwing should appear in this game. Simply playing with Batman was enough for me in Asylum. The use of Oracle (Barbara Gordon) as an emotional tie to Commissioner Gordon during his kidnapping was a nice touch, and I wouldn’t mind seeing her return. But I’d also like to hear from Alfred in Arkham City. We don’t need to actually see him (a la Oracle or The Riddler in the first game), but he’s too big a part of the Batman mythos to not have him play at least a small role. And on the off chance they can get 91-year-old Efrem Zimbalist, Jr. (who voiced the character in Batman: The Animated Series) to play him, more power to them!
As for characters like Robin, Nightwing or Batgirl, if they can find ways to conveniently fit them into the story, I’m fine with that. But Paul Dini and the rest of the storytellers certainly don’t need to go out of their way to include them. A subtle nod would be nice I suppose. Case in point, in Asylum we heard some broadcasts by reporter Jack Ryder, who in the DC Universe is also the anti-hero The Creeper. Little things like that are always fun.
5. Give Mark Hamill a Killing Joke Moment
Mark Hamill, who’s voiced The Joker in various cartoons and video games for about 20 years now, has gone on record saying Arkham City will be his final performance as the clown prince of crime. What brought him into the first game was apparently the chance to work with Paul Dini, who he cited as his “favorite Joker writer.”
Apparently Hamill is hesitant to return to the part for fear of not living up to previous performances. Personally, when it comes to the Joker, I think at this point Hamill could totally phone it in and still be better than 90 percent of the other actors that attempt to play the part. But on the other hand, I understand wanting to go out on a high note, and give other actors a chance to play the character.
In show business, you rarely say “never.” Heck, who’d have thought we’d see additional sequels to Indiana Jones and Rocky after all those years? But just in case this is Hamill’s last go around as the comic book world’s most infamous villain, I say we let him go out with a bang, and give him a scene or two that’s reminiscent of arguably the most famous Joker story ever: The Killing Joke.
Now, obviously we don’t want to pull specific circumstances or lines from the book, lest Alan Moore get on his high horse and tell fans never to play the game. But Hamill has said in the past that he’s be interested in doing an animated version of Moore’s famous graphic novel. But why not let Hamill tackle some scenes that are thematically similar? One scene from the book that comes to mind is the one where Batman is walking through Joker’s demented funhouse, and he’s giving his famous “one bad day” speech. Give Hamill something even remotely similar to that, and I guarantee you he’ll hit it out of the park. Mark Hamill deserves a moment like that after all the fantastic performances he’s given us over the years.
At this point, the only REAL drawback to Arkham City is that we have to wait a year to play it. It’s already got a lot of anticipation and high expectations building up for it. Whether that will help or hurt it, only time will tell.






























