ARTIST: Steven Wilson
ALBUM TITLE: Grace for Drowning
RECORD LABEL: Kscope
RELEASED:September 27, 2011
By Justin Polak
Co-founder, Ambassador to the Mushroom Kingdom
Having arrived just after Fear of a Blank Planet was released, I was late to the Porcupine Tree party. Since I grew up on prog, as some frequent readers have no doubt noticed by now, it’s obvious that I latched on to the band immediately and quickly became familiar with their entire discography. In fact, Porcupine Tree is the first band since Nine Inch Nails where I obsessively looked for various versions of albums, songs, bootlegs and b-sides. I’m kind of a passive person when it comes to music, too. While I certainly don’t stick to only what’s on the radio and listen to a song or two from a band, it takes something special for me to really dig down to the core.
When Insurgentes dropped in late 2008, I was pleasantly surprised to hear what Steven Wilson could do when free of Porcupine Tree. I liked how noisy the album seemed at times, and it was executed in a way where it didn’t interfere with the music. Hey, like I implied, I like Nine Inch Nails. I also got kind of a Radio Head vibe from certain tracks as well. Most obviously, I loved the giant nods to bands like The Cure (for example, “Puncture Wound” was like a slowed down “A Forest”). Overall, I would say that the album was liked a warped Porcupine Tree work, but with plenty of originality behind it where the tracks didn’t seem like cut material.
Grace for Drowning is an entirely different beast. Wilson has managed to pull off a pure experimental, psychedelic and progressive album that somehow seems more contained than his previous effort. What also amazes me is that the album is very much an homage to early ’70s prog, but simultaneously feels like a brand new experience. Another positive contradiction is how quiet the album is, yet it manages to be engaging and fierce sounding, like watching a thousands of tornadoes in the distance.
I also get sort of a sad and tragic feeling when listening to Grace for Drowning. I generally enjoy albums with that type of feeling, but usually I stray away from them at times because I don’t want to feel negative emotions. Yet, this is an album I can fully enjoy regardless if I am in a terrible mood or am having the best day of my life. Again, I notice a contradiction that I don’t mind because the end result somehow makes sense.
The album opens unsuspectingly with the title track, “Grace For Downing.” I mean, chances are you’ve heard plenty of instrumental openings that are short, piano driven pieces. However, “Sectarian” keeps the instrumental nature going, but comes out swinging with its chaotic, driving guitar and a chorus sound that brings various points of the song to an exciting climax. While the track slows down a bit and shows the first sign of ’70s prog on the album, rest assured you’ll find yourself thrown right back where you started by the time its over.

“Deform To Form A Star” finally brings us vocals, and while the song certainly has a somber opening and closing, it generally feels like venturing on a long journey. Or at the very least, knowing like you have rough times ahead of you. The lyrics may not reflect what I just described, but I am more of a musical person than a lyrical. Also worthy of note, this is the only track that carries anything remotely close to a Porcupine Tree song. I would place it somewhere around In Absentia.
The next track, “No Part Of Me” really caught my ears right off the bat with it’s electronic sprinkling and beat. It was about here on my first listen that I was almost sure that it was truly turning out to be one of the best albums I’ve heard in ages. If anything, the flow of this track leads seamlessly into an exciting build up that would probably work perfectly with an action scene in a David Fincher movie.
Though “Postcard” kind of changes the pace to a lighter and softer ballad-like piece, the end section, though obvious sounding, works to the album’s advantage. Yeah, there are plenty of songs like this one, but given the nature of GfD, it fits in just fine. Plus, I like how it contrasts with the next track, “Raider Prelude.” Though the track it’s foreshadowing sounds very different, it still gave me the chills. That damn scary Steven Wilson piano strikes again!
“Remainder The Black Dog” closes out the first disc with a sound somewhat reminiscent of “Sectarian,” but the key difference is that the jazz elements on the album pop up while effortlessly coexisting with the overall sound the album has formed for itself at this point. All in all, this is a perfect place to leave the album off on an intermission. I especially like the electronic guitar with the both piano arrangements.
A haunting guitar and keyboards carry us into the second disc with “Belle De Jour.” Though I risk pissing people off and ousting myself as a true dork by making this upcoming comparison, but I can’t help but be reminded of a Final Fantasy track when listening to it. Perhaps it would have played in a ghost town or a similar setting? Anyway, it manages to differentiate from the instrumental opening of the first disc, but still retains the journey that album has been taking the listener in on the first place.
“Index” is unquestionably my favorite track on this album. Once again, subtle electronic elements are brought to the table, and I just can’t resist the menacing scent the song breathes. Call me crazy, but I also get a hint of Peter Gabriel when the song gets louder and more active. Well, “Track One” brings the album back to more of a minimalistic quiet haze, and seems to want to stick around into the lighter side of late ’60s rock until an explosion of noise builds up more and more, expectantly fades out and closes with a relaxed guitars.

What follows next is certainly meant to be the centerpiece of the album. Clocking in at an impressive 23 minutes, “Raider II” opens ominously, like something very unfriendly is headed your way. Once again, the song gets loud with the same type of chorus sound found in “Sectarian.” From there, the song becomes on epic duel of jazz and prog. On top of all that, much of the song is is backed by a flute that often goes on its own path with some badass soloing. Sometimes crafting a long song is risky because if it doesn’t work, you wasted a good chunk of your album. Thankfully, this track does not venture into that pitfall. If anything, it’s one of my new favorite long songs in my music collection.
Finally, the album comes to a close with “Like Dust I have Cleared From My Eye.” Generally, this track has the perfect “end of album” feel to it without sounding too cliche’. Once again, Wilson softly jams on his guitar as the backbone song marches on. Then, fittingly, the song fades out slowly, as if it knows that its part of an album that has left a notable mark on the world.
I am sure you have guessed by now that I enjoyed the album. In fact, Grace for Drowning has done something it has never done to me before. Like many albums like this one, I can tell when a track is long when listening to it. Besides “Raider II,” there are many tracks that made me double take when I looked at the track time. I found myself so immersed in this album that there were many instances where a seven or ten minute song merely felt like three or four minutes. Also, when someone from a band releases a solo album, no matter how much I like the effort I usually think something along the lines of, “Well, that was nice, but I can’t wait to hear [band's next album].” For a change, I actually am looking forward to another Steven Wilson project than anything else he is attached to!
RATING: 9.5/10
Front page photo/photo #2 from awenwoods.com, photo #1 from hangout.altsounds.com.