Justice League: Cry For Justice -Graphic Novel Review
- June 1st, 2010
- By Rob
- Write comment
TITLE: Justice League: Cry For Justice
AUTHOR: James Robinson,
PENCILLERS: Mauro Cascioli, Scott Clark, Ibraim Roberson
COLLECTS: Justice League: Cry For Justice #1-7
FORMAT: Hardcover
PUBLISHER: DC Comics
PRICE: $24.99
RELEASE DATE: June 2
By Rob Siebert
Editor, Fanboy Wonder
Cry For Justice is a story about ethics among superheroes, the right thing to do versus the wrong thing to do. It asks questions about brutality, torture, and of course, the big question every fanboy asks at some point…
Why doesn’t the hero just kill the villain, and end the threat once and for all?
The premise is great. But the execution is kinda weird.
By my estimation, this story begins shortly after Final Crisis, and ends shortly after Blackest Night. So you’ve got to figure this book spans at least a couple of months. Angered after the deaths of Batman and Martian Manhunter, Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) demands the Justice League start living up to its name, and start taking on a more proactive agenda against evil, as opposed to simply putting out fires. When the League disagrees, Hal and Green Arrow (Oliver Queen) strike out on their own. Eventually, their little band of rebels grows to include The Atom (Ray Palmer), Supergirl and Captain Marvel, Starman and Congorilla (He’s a talking gorilla. That’s right, got a problem with that?)
The group investigates a plot involving dozens of supervillains, led by Prometheus, a villain who can exploit the weaknesses of the JLA using an advanced computer program that feeds information directly into his brain. Though the heroes take Prometheus lightly at first, the ramifications of what he does in this story will likely be felt for a long time.
The core story in this book, the one dealing with ethics and conduct, has a lot of meat to it and is very interesting. But it feels like there’s a lot of fat that could have been trimmed.
It should be noted that this group of heroes was originally going to be something of a Justice League B-Squad, an internal affairs type group. That idea was approved, but later nixed. I feel like James Robinson may have started writing the book as a smaller-scale story, then abruptly had the rug pulled out from under him, and had to blow it up. I say that because when the book’s climax begins, the core team has been joined by several additional heroes in the fight against Prometheus. It basically becomes a giant free-for-all.
Also, the dialogue during the first half of the book is inexplicably awkward and…wordy. There’s really no other way to put it. Robinson usually doesn’t have a problem with dialogue, but it feels like he came down with Revenge of the Sith syndrome here.
A brief example: There’s a scene where Supergirl comes in and saves Green Lantern from an attack. Hal says: “All right Supergirl, here you are. And you saved my life — much appreciated by the way. But I still have to ask — Are you here now as a hero…or as a villain?”
See? Needlessly wordy, not to mention corny. In any other book, I bet that quote would have been cut in half. But for some reason those kind of lines pop up all over Cry For Justice.
You’re also expected to know who most (if not all) of these heroes are when you open the book. One of the biggest plot twists in the book involves Red Arrow, Green Arrow’s former sidekick, who doesn’t even come into the book until about the halfway point.
Still, it has it’s high points. One thing nobody can take away from the book is the art of Mauro Cascioli. It’s among the best I’ve seen in the modern era. During the latter half of the book, Scott Clark inexplicably takes over for a bit, which I take as yet another indicator that this book didn’t go as planned.
Robinson’s portrayal of Congorilla is charming, and the scenes in which The Atom tortures the villains are very intriguing. Also, despite the book’s flaws, the ending packs a major punch.
Though it certainly helped shape events to come in the DCU (particularly for Green Arrow and Red Arrow) Cry For Justice had a very flimsy execution. It’s a good story, but only if you look hard enough.
RATING: 5.5/10
























