First Impressions: Red Hood: The Lost Days #1
- June 3rd, 2010
- By Rob
- Write comment
TITLE: Red Hood: The Lost Days #1 (0f 6)
AUTHOR: Judd Winick
PENCILLER: Pablo Raimondi
PUBLISHER: DC Comics
PRICE: $2.99
RELEASE DATE: June 3
By Rob Siebert
Editor, Fanboy Wonder
**SPOILERS AHEAD**
To coincide with DC Entertainment’s latest direct-to-DVD animated feature, Batman: Under The Red Hood (which comes out next month), DC Comics has reunited Judd Winick with Jason Todd, a.k.a. The Red Hood. Fittingly, Winick not only wrote the movie, but the story arc it’s based upon, which reinstated the Jason Todd character into Batman’s world.
This story is meant to bridge a bit more of the gap between Jason’s resurrection, and his battles with Batman, which were first published a few years ago. The issue begins with Ra’s al Ghul and his daughter Talia discovering that Jason Todd, the second boy to be given the mantle of Robin, has been savagely murdered by The Joker. Given her feelings for Bruce Wayne, Talia feels for him. A short time later, she learns that Jason has somehow survived, but is a shell of his former self. He can’t speak or communicate, but when provoked, his fighting instincts kick in. Jason is in Talia’s care for over a year before Ra’s grows tired with his lack of progress, and orders that he be sent away. We close the book as Talia is about to place Jason in a Lazarus Pit to revive his mind.
The ironic thing about this miniseries being called The Lost Days is that it starts with a rehash of a story that’s already been told. In spring 2006, DC published Batman Annual #25, in which ALL these plot points were revealed for the first time. Essentially this is the same story, some scenes complete with verbatim dialogue, told through Talia’s eyes. We’re not getting a lot of fresh content here, thus, this issue lacks the hook that first issues typically have, as we already know what’s coming in issue #2.
In Winick’s defense, the issue is titled “Prologue,” so technically we’re not digging into the meat and potatoes of the story yet. But I feel like Winick could have trimmed the fat a little bit, so that we could have at least gotten Jason started on his “lost” journey by the issue’s end.
One aspect of this issue that bothered me is that Winick dances around how Jason was actually brought back to life. If you’ve read Batman Annual #25, you know it’s because of Superboy Prime’s actions prior to Infinite Crisis (he essentially caused a cosmic rift that brought Jason back to life). But if you’re picking up this issue with no knowledge of that, all you know is that he dug his way out of his coffin, and was found in his semi-responsive state. How this boy, who was beaten to death with a crowbar and then blown up, came back to life is information the reader should know up front, rather than to have to guess. Either Winick and DC are planning something with that later in the series, or it’s simply a mind boggling mistake.
I’m also not a fan of how Pablo Raimondi kept Jason’s body so chiseled. It’s that over-muscled style that you see in so many superhero books. I wouldn’t necessarily have a problem with it, if this child weren’t in a mostly vegetative state, and didn’t use his body when he wasn’t being attacked. That being said, some of the facial expressions we see on Talia in this issue are strong.
Talia is the one character that comes out of this issue better than she went in. One plot element Winick adds with Lost Days #1 is that Talia cared for Jason because she wanted Bruce Wayne to love her. What better way to win a man’s love than to return his dead son to him? Thus, we get a little more insight into why she placed him into the Lazarus Pit. There’s also a very nice exchange where Talia is talking to the unresponsive Jason about how much Bruce misses him, and a single tear falls from the boy’s eye. A little cliche, but touching nonetheless.
I’m happy Judd Winick is getting the chance to work with Jason Todd again, as I enjoyed Under The Hood. But The Lost Days #1 felt more like a sequence of deleted scenes than anything else. Hopefully we can actually get the ball rolling in the next issue.
NOTE: The cover shown above is a variant. A portion of the regular cover is shown in this piece’s feature image (from ComicArtCommunity.com).



















